Blog Post

Smart Parking Systems by Parking BOXX

STAFFING A GATED PARKING SYSTEM VS. A METERED PARKING SYSTEM

Parking BOXX • May 04, 2017

A Comparison of Costs

In a recent post, we explored the pros and cons of gated versus metered systems , with a focus on costs and revenues. We wrote about how these parking systems compare when it comes to capital costs, maintenance and more, and also how the revenue capture differs.

This post zeros in on the issue of staffing a metered or a gated parking system.

Parking staff represent the most significant ongoing cost for any parking operation . Many parking operators are interested in reducing staff levels, but it’s important to understand how different parking systems facilitate or limit automation.

Staffing Requirements for Gated Parking Systems

A gated parking system is more complex, and traditionally, gated lots have required a constant staff presence. Today, functions typically performed by cashiers - issuing tickets and processing payments - can be fully automated.

That doesn't mean that gated parking facilities run with no human intervention. There are still instances where a parking customer needs assistance. They may have lost or damaged their ticket, or the customer may have an issue with the fee, the parking machines or gates.

In a gated lot or garage, assistance can be provided remotely through video monitoring and telecoms. Instead of having on-site attendants dedicated to a single site, one parking attendant can monitor and provide support to multiple parking lots from a remote parking admin office.

What about technicians for maintenance ?

Staff are needed to periodically collect cash payments from the parking payment machines, replace paper in printers and perform other routine tasks. But compared to the cost of staffing a gated parking system with on-site cashiers and attendants, these maintenance costs are negligible.

From a management perspective, a gated system can require more complex administration than a simple metered system. There are more options for payment schedules, validations and monthly parking arrangements than in a metered parking system. These variable rates require some oversight, but can be effectively managed with high-performing parking management software, like EASE.

Staffing Requirements for Metered Parking Systems

Meters have the advantage of being self-serve when it comes to ticketing and payment. Because there are no gates, meter customers are also less likely to encounter issues and require on-site assistance.

Like gated pay-on-foot systems, meters do require staff to collect cash payments from machines periodically, and technicians to maintain the equipment. This labor is, however, not the most significant staffing cost.

If you haven’t read our mega-post on Gated vs. Metered Parking Systems , we’re spoiling the big reveal here. The surprising fact is that over the life of the equipment, meters can be more expensive than gated systems. And it all comes down to enforcement costs .

A significant enforcement presence is essential to a metered parking system. Without enforcement, parking payment non-compliance would take a serious bite out of revenues. Even in areas with compliance rates deemed “high”, and with vigilant enforcement, a significant percent of motorists will not pay their full meter fee.

Today, new enforcement technologies are making enforcement more efficient. Hand-held and vehicle-mounted License Plate Recognition (LPR) technologies help agents scan plates and check for corresponding payments more quickly. In some cases, enforcement officers don’t even need to physically cite vehicles. Instead, photographic image of license plates are sent back to a central processing area, and tickets for confirmed violations can be issued by mail.

Even with these advancements, meter enforcement is a relatively staff-intensive process. Whenever parking fees are in effect at meters, enforcement officers must be present.

Staffing of Metered Parking Systems in Garages: An Exception to the Rule

There is a hybrid parking system that presents an exception. Most parking garages are gated, and most meters are found on street parking. That said, it is possible to use meters in an ungated parking garage and yes, save on staffing costs.

Stationary LPR technology at the entrances and exits to a parking garage can capture infractions automatically, without enforcement staff on site. This LPR system would work in combination with pay-by-plate meters in the garage. As mentioned above, the LPR technology can capture potential violations and after the cases are reviewed centrally, fines can be issued by mail.

At present, this automatic enforcement only works in a garage setting , where traffic necessarily flows through single points of entry and exit.

Why would anyone choose meters in a parking garage? As noted in our longer post, the upfront capital cost of installing meters is lower, as are the warranty and maintenance costs. Some parking garage owners also like the fact that using meters allows for faster flow-through of traffic.

The best of both worlds? Almost. Even LPR technology cannot capture 100% of parking fees, and in that sense doesn’t yet compare with a gated parking system’s secure revenue collection.

Adding Up the Staffing Costs of Parking Systems

If you’ve read our outline of the costs and revenues of metered and gated parking systems , you’ll know that both can yield a very high ROI.

Still, it’s important for anyone considering a metered parking system to be aware that enforcement staffing costs drive up the long-run operational costs. Salaries and benefits far outweigh other ongoing operational costs.

New technologies are introducing automation to metered parking enforcement. In the future, we may find that even on-street meter parking enforcement can be further automated, lowering staff costs and bringing revenue collection closer to that of gated parking systems.

Talk to Parking BOXX About Metered and Gated Parking Systems

Considering a new parking system? Parking BOXX gated and metered parking systems are top quality. Our customers often say that Parking BOXX equipment ‘just works’, which means less time spent by technicians on maintenance.

Plus, our “Best Price Guarantee” policy means that if you can find an equivalent total parking system at a lower price, we’ll beat our competitor’s pricing by 5%.

Call us at 800-518-1230 or request a demo at https://parkingboxx.com/request-a-demo/

Parking Barrier Gate
By Parking BOXX 01 Dec, 2021
Parking solutions are anything that helps the traffic flow and security of a parking lot or garage. Barrier gates can work in a lot of different ways. This will depend on your parking area's needs and payment processes.Barrier gates, or parking gates, are a very common parking solution.
By Parking BOXX 19 Mar, 2020
"You can only control what you can control."
By Parking BOXX 04 Dec, 2019
4 steps to parking lot design & parking lot layout. Review these steps to quickly prepare a layout to determine how many parking spaces will fit into your lot.
By Parking BOXX 01 May, 2019
At Parking BOXX, we get calls from all types of industries asking about our parking equipment: from retail, to university campuses, hospitals, and campgrounds. But we have to admit: it’s not every day we get a phone call from a hit television show asking to feature a parking machine , our parking payment machine in a murder mystery show. Much to our surprise, that’s exactly what happened when Private Eyes , Global’s hit television series slated to return come spring 2019, reached out. Now on its third season, the show follows the antics of Matt Shade and Angie Everett. He’s an ex-professional Hockey player, she’s a no-nonsense P.I. They join forces to solve mysteries every week with equal parts wit and humor. Filmed and set in Toronto, the show has a refreshing take on the city—it embraces its nooks and crannies, the glamour as much as the grit, which makes for a fun and authentic portrayal of this vibrant Canadian city. But to the more pressing question: why would the show, unless it’s building a state-of-the-art parking facility, contact us about parking equipment? As with any good mystery show, the puzzle is always solved by a leap in thought: something about the environment tips the detectives off, and through a series of mental maneuvers, they decipher who the culprit is, catch the bad guy, and restore justice. Viewers are left satisfied until a new mystery takes centre stage the following week. Season three, like the other two before it, will be rife with mysteries and suspense at every corner of Matt and Angie’s journey. As it turns out, Private Eyes will not be building the parking garage of our dreams anytime soon. Instead, this upcoming season, Parking BOXX’s very own parking machine will act as the key to one of its mysteries, and we couldn’t be more thrilled to see what the writers come up with. Stay tuned to catch us on the small screen.
By Parking BOXX 01 Feb, 2019
At Parking BOXX, we expect a lot from our employees—it’s in our CORE values. To bring you the best services and support, we encourage our employees to carry out the following four value pillars: C ustomers, O rganization, R esults, and E xcellence, the —CORE in our CORE values. A company that expects a lot, however, must also give a lot. Far removed from the early models of productivity that looked at employees like machines, we know that to yield the best from our employees, we must provide services that will allow them to thrive personally and professionally. This is why we’re always thinking about ways to improve our work atmosphere [link to office art article], and this means thinking about the day-to-day experiences of employees at the office. Study after study has shown that prolonged periods of sitting causes harms to the body. It puts undue pressure on the neck, shoulders, and spine, results in back pain and conditions like carpal tunnel, all of which exacerbate one’s propensity for physiological and psychological malaises such as: increased blood pressure, stress, and anxiety. Not only does this stall productivity, it lowers morale and causes dissatisfaction at work. Since we are only as strong as our employees, we know that dissatisfaction hinders our ability to give you the best customer service in the industry. In seeking a way to remedy the imbalance caused by extended periods of sitting, we implemented the Employee Massage Program, in which our employees sign up for a massage during the workday. Why massage? The answer to this was easy. By releasing tension accumulated thanks to extended periods of sitting, massage helps alleviate both physiological and psychological stresses. As Matt, one of our employees put it, “Having a sedentary job, I feel like my muscles are joints are stiffening up throughout the day. When we get massages, even if they are only 20 minutes, it definitely gets rid of some aches. After the massage, I feel like I’m ready to get back to work. Happy employees make for productive workers. Implementing the massage program is a smart solution, creating a win-win situation for both our employees and customers. Unsurprisingly, we’ve received nothing but positive feedback from our employees. Praise of the stress-alleviating effects include: “Fantastic! I feel lighter, my arms are less heavy.” “I feel great. I don’t feel tired, I feel refreshed.” “I always have a good night’s sleep the day of the massage,” Implementing the program during the work day has also been one of its major successes. While other companies aim to fulfil the same goals by offering employees extensive health packages, a busy work schedule often causes people to forget or neglect to book a massage appointment. “I love that BOXX has a massage program offered during office hours. Due to my busy schedule both at work and at home, I don’t really have time for me. A massage time allows me to take care of myself and my health,” said one of our Sales Team members. At Parking BOXX, we’re delighted with the results of our massage program: through it, we fulfil our CORE values mission so that our employees may continue to offer the industry’s best customer service!
By Parking BOXX 27 Oct, 2018
At Parking BOXX we care about people. We care about providing you with the best and most responsive Support that the parking industry has to offer. We care about our employees, about fostering professional and personal growth in order to bring our best selves forward. But we don’t stop there. We can’t, in fact, because we know that surrounding each member of our Team are groups of people that help the personal growth process in ways that we can’t. This is why we like to get involved with causes that affect our community—particularly those that affect our Team members’ friends and families. This quarter, the Team at Parking BOXX culled their efforts to raise funds for Diabetes Canada by donating clothing, accessories, and household items. The collection drive was spearheaded by Shannon, our Social Media and Marketing Specialist who is also our charity-drive organizing superstar. She took the time to educate the Team, set up reminders at company offices, and motivated everyone to participate. Behind this goal was the desire to support a cause that affected various members of our Team. “A couple of co-workers have family and friends that have diabetes,” she said, “My best friend also has diabetes. Diabetes is one of those illnesses that create radical changes to your life. And it doesn’t just affect the person who has it. It affects the whole family.” According to Diabetes Canada, 5.7 million Canadians over the age of twenty are affected by diabetes. Along with the immediate effects of the illness, like having to regulate one’s diet and glucose levels, having diabetes comes with other lifestyle changes. Thirty percent of people with diabetes, for example, experience depressive symptoms. In support of the cause, our Team donated everything from clothes, pots and pans, jewelry and hats. Diabetes Canada partners up with Value Village to sell these donations and raise money for various diabetes-related causes. Part of the money goes towards funding diabetes research in Canada, which has always been exceptional. After all, insulin, the protein associated with diabetes, was first discovered by Frederick Banting and Charles H. Best in Toronto. Part of the proceeds also go towards funding D-camps— camps tailored for kids with type 1 diabetes. Thanks to Shannon’s organizational skills, our Team rounded up enough items to fill seven large boxes —boxes big enough fit our parking kiosks! She made the giving process convenient, which often deters people from donating altogether. As one of our employees put it, “The initiative was fantastic. I have lots of clothes and I was very eager to bring them in to the office and have them taken. This is a very easy way to be a charitable good person”. Organizing these types of charitable drives are and easy way to bring the Team together while making valuable and important contributions to the community. We congratulate Shannon and our Team for making this drive such a success and look forward to the next one.
By Parking BOXX 24 Oct, 2018
Learn more about factors to consider for a parking pay station purchase
By Parking BOXX 26 Jun, 2018
Parking control equipment allows parking lot and garage owners and managers to restrict access to their lot as well as generate revenue. Parking control systems improve security, restrict vehicle access to specified areas, track who entered these specific areas, when they enter and exit, allow passback restrictions to be set, generate revenue, and provide reporting capabilities. When parking gate systems are utilized, this allows the system to control the entry and exit lanes of the facility or lot. Specific entrances may permit only proximity or long range card holders to enter. Public entrances may incorporate such readers as well as ticket printing or pre-paid entry. For persons receiving tickets upon entry, parking payments may be made at walk-up Pay Stations or upon exiting the lot. Exit lanes may incorporate Exit Stations with credit/debit card only payments, cash and credit/debit payment or Cashier Stations. Importantly, barrier gates secure all laneways to ensure that only valid card or credential holders or paid ticket holders are granted permission to leave as well as to prevent unauthorized ingress or egress. In addition to the above mentioned lane way equipment and payment terminals, Validation and Hotel Guest Check in Terminals may be incorporated to enhance the automated parking control system.
By Parking BOXX 02 Jan, 2018
Are you looking for a Parking Equipment Show to view the latest parking lot equipment and smart parking systems ? If so, here's a list of major industry events for 2018. DATE LINK NAME LOCATION Mar 26-29 PIE Exhibition Parking Industry Exhibition (PIE) Rosemont, IL, USA Apr 24-26 Seguidad Expo Seguidad Mexico Mexico City, Mexico May 5 MAPA MAPA Spring CME Conference Novi, MI Mar 26-29 TPTA 2018 TPTA Annual Conference & Tradeshow Houston, Texas June 13-14 Parkex Parkex The Ricoh, Judds Lane, Coventry Oct 10-12 PAV PAV Annual Fall Workshop and Tradeshow Richmond, VA Apr 24-27 PAG 2018 PAG Conference Augusta, GA May 28-30 Intertraffic Intertraffic China 2018 Shanghai, China May 14-15 NEPC NEPC'S 23rd Annual Investment Conference Boston, MA June 3-6 IPI Conference & Expo International Parking Institute Conference & Expo Kissimmee, FL July 25-27 PIPTA 2018 PIPTA Conference and Expo Portland, OR Sept 3-5 Parking China Parking China Shanghai, China Oct 25-27 Parking Infra Tech Expo Parking Infra Tech Expo Mumbai, India Oct 24-26 IDA IDA 64th Annual Conference & Tradeshow San Antonio, TX Oct 31-Nov 2 PACE2018 Parking Australia Convention & Exhibition Gold Coast, Queensland, Australia Sept 25-29 CPA Fall Conference 2018 CPA Conference & Trade Show Hilton head, South Carolina May 2-4 PPA 2018 Pennsylvania Parking Association (PPA) Spring Conference & Trade Show Pittsburgh, PA Oct 3-5 FPA FPA Annual Conference Chicago, IL Oct 22-25 NPA NPA Annual Convention & Expo Las Vegas, NV Sept 16-19 CPA 2018 Conference and Trade Show Toronto, ON Nov 13-15 Intertraffic Mexico Intertraffic Mexico Mexico City, Mexico Nov 7-9 CPPA 2018 Annual CPPA Conference & Trade Show Los Angeles, CA
By Parking BOXX 10 Jul, 2017
7 Reasons to Install a Parking System Why automate? Here are 7 reasons to automate your Parking Access and Revenue Control System with Parking BOXX:
Show More
Share by: